What is FOIL/FOIA?
Every level of government in the United States — federal, state, and local — is required by law to give you access to its records when you ask. These laws go by different names depending on the jurisdiction:
- FOIA (Freedom of Information Act) is the federal law, enacted in 1966.
- FOIL (Freedom of Information Law) is what New York calls its state version.
- Other states use names like Open Records Act, Public Records Law, Right to Know Law, or Sunshine Law.
The principle behind all of these laws is the same: the public has a right to know what its government is doing. The records that government agencies create and maintain — emails, contracts, reports, inspection records, spending data, meeting minutes, police reports — belong to the public unless a specific legal exemption applies.
Who can file a request?
Anyone. In most jurisdictions, you do not need to be a resident, a citizen, or even explain why you want the records. The right to request public records extends to:
Individual citizens
Any person, regardless of residency
Journalists
Investigative reporting and newsgathering
Businesses
Competitive research, compliance, due diligence
Law firms
Discovery support, client advocacy, litigation prep
Nonprofit organizations
Advocacy, watchdog functions, policy research
Academic researchers
Studies, data analysis, public policy work
Key point: Agencies are generally prohibited from asking why you want the records. Your purpose for the request is irrelevant to whether the records must be disclosed.
What you can request
Public records laws cover an extremely broad range of government documents. If a government agency created it, received it, or maintains it, it is probably subject to disclosure. Common examples include:
- Government contracts and procurement records
- Emails and correspondence between officials
- Police reports and incident records
- Inspection and compliance reports
- Budget documents and spending data
- Meeting minutes and agendas
- Permit applications and approvals
- Personnel records (with some privacy limitations)
- Agency policies and procedural manuals
What is typically exempt
Exemptions vary by jurisdiction, but common categories of records that agencies can withhold include:
- Records that would endanger safety — information that could put someone at physical risk
- Active law enforcement investigations — records that would interfere with an ongoing case
- Personal privacy information — Social Security numbers, medical records, and similar private data (though agencies must often redact rather than withhold entirely)
- Attorney-client privileged materials — communications between the agency and its lawyers
- Trade secrets and proprietary information — confidential business information submitted to the agency
- Internal deliberative materials — pre-decisional drafts and discussions (with significant limitations on this exemption)
Important: Exemptions are narrowly construed. The burden is on the agency to prove why a record qualifies for an exemption. If an agency denies your request, you have the right to appeal.
What to expect
The process follows a predictable pattern in most jurisdictions, though timelines vary:
| Stage | Typical Timeline | What Happens |
|---|---|---|
| Acknowledgment | 3–10 business days | Agency confirms it received your request |
| Response | 5–30 business days | Agency grants, denies, or partially fulfills the request |
| Fees (if any) | Varies | Some agencies charge per-page copying fees; many are free for electronic copies |
| Appeal (if denied) | 30 days to file | File an administrative appeal to the agency head |
FOIL Tracker handles all of this. When you create a request, the platform automatically calculates every deadline based on the jurisdiction and alerts you before each one. You do not need to look up the deadlines yourself.
Common mistakes to avoid
Being too vague
"All records about the budget" is too broad. "Budget allocation reports for the Department of Education for fiscal year 2024" gives the agency something to work with.
Being too specific
Do not ask for a document by a title you are guessing. Describe the type of record and the subject matter, and let the agency identify the specific documents.
Sending to the wrong office
FOIL requests go to the agency's designated Records Access Officer, not the general inbox. FOIL Tracker's agency directory has the correct contacts.
Not tracking deadlines
Agencies count on requesters losing track. If you do not follow up when a deadline passes, the request dies quietly. FOIL Tracker prevents this.
Accepting a denial without appealing
Many denials are reversed on appeal. If an agency denies your request, you have the legal right to challenge the denial. Do not assume the agency is correct.
Not documenting everything
If you ever need to take an agency to court, you need a documented record of every communication. FOIL Tracker maintains this audit trail automatically.