New York FOIL Guide

Everything you need to know about the Freedom of Information Law — deadlines, appeals, enforcement, and best practices.

1. What Is FOIL?

The Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) is New York State's open records statute, codified in Public Officers Law, Article 6, Sections 84–90. Enacted in 1974 and substantially amended in 1977 and 2008, FOIL establishes a presumption that all government records are available for public inspection and copying unless specifically exempted by law.

FOIL is the state-level equivalent of the federal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA, 5 U.S.C. § 552), but it applies to state and local agencies in New York — not federal agencies. Federal agencies are governed exclusively by FOIA.

The foundational principle of FOIL is stated in Section 84:

“The people's right to know the process of governmental decision-making and to review the documents and statistics leading to determinations is basic to our society. Access to such information should not be thwarted by shrouding it in secrecy or combative litigation.”
— N.Y. Pub. Off. Law § 84

2. Who Can File a FOIL Request?

Any person may file a FOIL request. There is no standing requirement, no citizenship requirement, and no requirement to state a reason or purpose for the request. Under Section 89(3), agencies may not inquire into the purpose of a request as a basis for granting or denying access. This means:

  • New York residents and non-residents alike may file
  • Individuals, businesses, law firms, journalists, and organizations may all file
  • You do not need to explain why you want the records
  • The agency cannot deny access based on who is requesting or why
  • Requests can be submitted by anyone — attorneys, paralegals, staff, or the public

3. What Agencies Are Covered?

FOIL applies to all “agencies” as defined in Section 86(3), which includes:

  • All state executive branch agencies and departments
  • The legislature (to a limited extent)
  • All municipal agencies (cities, counties, towns, villages)
  • School districts and BOCES
  • Public authorities and public benefit corporations
  • Local development corporations created by government
  • Fire districts and special districts
  • Community colleges

Not covered: The judiciary (courts), private entities, and the governor's executive chamber (though some records may be available through other means). Federal agencies operating in New York are covered by federal FOIA, not FOIL.

4. How to File a FOIL Request

FOIL requests should be submitted in writing to the agency's designated Records Access Officer (RAO). Every agency subject to FOIL is required to designate at least one RAO under Section 87(1)(b).

Required Elements

  • Identify the records you are seeking with reasonable specificity. You do not need to know the exact document title or file number, but the agency must be able to locate the records based on your description.
  • Address your request to the RAO or the agency's FOIL unit. Many agencies publish their RAO contact information on their websites.
  • State that the request is made under FOIL (Public Officers Law Article 6). While not strictly required, this ensures the agency processes it under the correct legal framework.

Submission Methods

Agencies must accept requests submitted by mail, but many also accept requests via:

  • Email (check the agency's website for the correct address)
  • Online portal (many state agencies use the NY FOIL Portal)
  • Fax
  • In person

Pro tip: Always request records in both physical and electronic format. Under Section 87(5)(a), agencies must provide records in the medium requested if the agency can reasonably make the copy.

5. Statutory Deadlines and Timeline

FOIL imposes specific deadlines on agencies. Understanding these deadlines is critical for tracking compliance and knowing when to escalate.

EventDeadlineStatute
Receipt acknowledgment5 business days from receipt§ 89(3)
Grant, deny, or provide response dateWithin acknowledgment (5 business days)§ 89(3)
Substantive response (produce records)“Reasonable time” — typically 20 business days§ 89(3)
Administrative appeal (after denial)30 days from denial§ 89(4)(a)
Agency response to appeal10 business days from receipt of appeal§ 89(4)(a)
Article 78 proceeding (judicial review)4 months from final agency determinationCPLR § 217

Key Details on the 5-Business-Day Rule

Within five business days of receipt, the agency must do one of three things:

  1. Grant the request and make the records available;
  2. Deny the request in writing, stating the specific exemption(s) and the right to appeal; or
  3. Acknowledge receipt and provide an approximate date (within a “reasonable time”) by which the request will be granted or denied.

If the agency fails to respond within five business days, the request is deemed constructively denied, and the requester may file an administrative appeal immediately.

What Is “Reasonable Time”?

The statute does not define a specific number for “reasonable time.” The Committee on Open Government (COG) has issued advisory opinions indicating that 20 business days is generally considered reasonable for most requests. However, this is a guideline, not a hard statutory limit. Factors that may extend a reasonable timeframe include:

  • Volume of records responsive to the request
  • Need to search multiple locations or departments
  • Need to redact exempt information
  • Consultation with other agencies or legal counsel

Important: Chronic or indefinite delay is not “reasonable.” If an agency provides an estimated date and then fails to meet it, the requester should follow up and, if necessary, treat the failure as a constructive denial.

6. Denials and Partial Denials

A denial of a FOIL request must:

  • Be in writing;
  • State the specific reason for denial, citing the applicable exemption(s) under Section 87(2);
  • Inform the requester of the right to appeal to the head of the agency or the person designated to hear appeals; and
  • Identify the appeal officer by name or title and provide instructions for filing an appeal.

A partial denial occurs when an agency releases some records but withholds others, or redacts portions of released records. For partial denials, the agency must identify the specific exemption for each withheld record or redaction. Blanket denials citing multiple exemptions without specifying which exemption applies to which record are improper.

Constructive denial: If the agency fails to respond at all within the statutory timeframe, the non-response is treated as a denial, and the requester may immediately appeal.

7. Administrative Appeal

Under Section 89(4)(a), a requester may appeal a denial (including a constructive denial) within 30 days of the denial. The appeal is filed with the head of the agency or the person designated to hear appeals.

How to File an Appeal

  1. Submit in writing to the agency's designated appeals officer.
  2. Reference the original request — include the date of the request, date of denial, and the records sought.
  3. State why the denial was improper — challenge the exemption cited, argue the records are not exempt, or note that the agency failed to provide a specific basis for denial.
  4. Request a determination within 10 business days as required by Section 89(4)(a).

Agency Response to Appeal

The agency must respond to the appeal within 10 business days. The response must either:

  • Grant the appeal and provide the records;
  • Deny the appeal with a written explanation and inform the requester of the right to judicial review; or
  • Partially grant the appeal (releasing some records, continuing to withhold others with a specific basis).

The agency must also send a copy of the appeal and its determination to the Committee on Open Government (COG).

8. Filing a COG Complaint

The Committee on Open Government (COG) is an advisory body within the New York Department of State that oversees compliance with FOIL and the Open Meetings Law. While COG does not have enforcement authority, its advisory opinions carry significant weight and are frequently cited by courts.

When to Contact COG

  • An agency has failed to respond to your request within the statutory timeframe
  • An agency denied your request improperly
  • An agency failed to respond to your administrative appeal within 10 business days
  • You need guidance on whether specific records are subject to FOIL

How to File

Contact the Committee on Open Government:

  • Email: coog@dos.ny.gov
  • Phone: (518) 474-2518
  • Mail: Committee on Open Government, Department of State, One Commerce Plaza, 99 Washington Avenue, Suite 650, Albany, NY 12231
  • Online: opengovernment.ny.gov

COG will review your complaint and issue an advisory opinion. While not legally binding, a COG advisory opinion finding that the agency violated FOIL is strong evidence in any subsequent judicial proceeding.

9. Article 78 Proceedings

If the administrative appeal is denied (or the agency fails to respond to the appeal within 10 business days), the requester may challenge the denial in court through an Article 78 proceeding under the New York Civil Practice Law and Rules (CPLR).

Key Points

  • Statute of limitations: The proceeding must be commenced within four months of the final agency determination (CPLR § 217).
  • Burden of proof: The burden is on the agency to demonstrate that the records are exempt from disclosure (Section 89(4)(b)).
  • Venue: The proceeding is filed in Supreme Court in the county where the agency is located or where the requester resides.
  • Attorney fees: Under Section 89(4)(c), the court may award reasonable attorney fees if the requester substantially prevails and the agency had no reasonable basis for denying access.
  • In camera inspection: The court may review the disputed records privately (“in camera”) to determine whether the claimed exemption applies.

Note: You must exhaust administrative remedies (file the internal appeal) before commencing an Article 78 proceeding. The exception is constructive denial through total non-response, where courts have permitted Article 78 proceedings without a prior appeal.

10. Common Exemptions

Section 87(2) lists the exemptions that agencies may invoke to withhold records. All exemptions are narrowly construed, and the burden is on the agency to prove applicability. The most commonly invoked exemptions include:

  • § 87(2)(a) — Specifically exempted by federal or state statute: Records protected by other laws (e.g., tax returns, sealed court records, medical records under HIPAA).
  • § 87(2)(b) — Unwarranted invasion of personal privacy: Protects personal information such as Social Security numbers, medical records, and similar private data. Agencies may redact identifying information rather than withholding the entire record.
  • § 87(2)(e) — Compiled for law enforcement: Records compiled for law enforcement purposes that would interfere with an investigation, deprive a person of a fair trial, or identify a confidential source.
  • § 87(2)(f) — Endanger life or safety: Records that, if disclosed, could endanger the life or safety of any person.
  • § 87(2)(g) — Inter-agency or intra-agency materials: Internal deliberative materials, drafts, and pre-decisional communications. However, this exemption does not apply to statistical or factual data, instructions to staff that affect the public, final agency policy determinations, or external audits.
  • § 87(2)(i) — Computer access codes and security information: Passwords, security codes, and information that would jeopardize computer security.

11. Fees and Costs

Under Section 87(1)(b)(iii), agencies may charge fees for copying records:

  • Photocopies (up to 9" x 14"): Maximum $0.25 per page
  • Electronic copies: The actual cost of the storage media (e.g., CD, USB drive) or, if transmitted electronically (email), no charge for the medium
  • Inspection: Free. Agencies may not charge for merely inspecting records at their offices.
  • Search fees: Agencies may not charge for the time spent searching for or preparing records.

Agencies may require payment of fees before providing copies. If the estimated cost exceeds $50, the agency may require a deposit.

12. Tips for Effective Requests

Be specific

Describe the records you want with enough detail for the agency to locate them. Include date ranges, department names, and record types when possible.

Know the agency

Research which agency holds the records you need. Sending a request to the wrong agency wastes time. Check the agency's website for its RAO contact information.

Request electronic copies

Always request records in electronic format. It's cheaper, faster, and agencies are required to provide electronic copies if they maintain the records electronically.

Keep records of everything

Document when you sent the request, when (and if) the agency acknowledged it, and every communication. This creates the evidentiary trail you need if you have to appeal.

Don't over-request

Overly broad requests (e.g., "all records about X") invite delays and claims that the request is too burdensome. Be targeted.

Follow up promptly

If the agency misses the 5-day acknowledgment window, follow up immediately. Silence is constructive denial — you can appeal right away.

Cite the statute

Reference "Public Officers Law Article 6" in your request. This ensures the agency processes it under FOIL rather than as a general inquiry.

Track deadlines ruthlessly

Use FOIL Tracker (or at minimum a calendar system) to track every deadline. The 5-day, 20-day, and 30-day windows are critical.

13. Full Statute and Resources

Disclaimer

This guide is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. FOIL Tracker is a management tool, not a law firm. For legal advice regarding FOIL requests, appeals, or Article 78 proceedings, consult a qualified attorney licensed to practice in New York.

Track every FOIL deadline automatically

FOIL Tracker calculates your 5-day, 20-day, and 30-day windows and alerts you before they expire.

Start Free Trial